Blog · Local search
Why only three businesses get seen.
Search for a service on your phone and Google shows a map with three businesses under it. What decides which three, what does not, and a ten-minute check you can run on your own listing today.
Pick up your phone and search for what you do, the way a customer would: "furnace repair near me", "dog groomer calgary", "brake job". Above the ordinary results there is a map, and under the map there are three businesses. Google calls this the local pack. Most people call it the map pack.
To see anyone else, the searcher has to tap through to the full list. Some do. A lot of people simply call one of the three, or tap through to one of their websites, and the search is over. If you are not in those three for the searches that matter to you, you are mostly not there at all.
That is the whole problem in one sentence. The rest of this post is what decides the three, what does not, and how to check where you stand in about ten minutes without paying anyone.
What decides the three
Google is unusually direct about this. Its own help page for business owners says local results are based mainly on three things: relevance, distance and prominence. It does not publish the weights, and anyone who tells you the exact formula is guessing. But the three factors are enough to work with.
Distance: where the searcher is standing
Google ranks a business partly on how far it is from the person searching, or from where Google thinks they are. You cannot change this, but you need to understand it, because it means there is no single ranking. The three businesses someone sees in Tuscany are not the three someone sees in Mahogany. When you search from your own shop, you are seeing the result for people standing at your shop, which is the most flattering result there is.
Relevance: does your profile say what they searched for
This is how well your Google Business Profile matches the search. Google reads your business categories, your services, your description and your website. The primary category matters most in my experience, because it is the plainest statement of what you are. A plumber listed as "Contractor" is asking Google to guess.
Prominence: how well known you are
This is Google's estimate of how established and trusted a business is. It says this includes how many other websites link to you and how many reviews you have, and that more reviews and positive ratings can help. This is often where a smaller business loses. The business with 180 reviews and a steady trickle of new ones usually beats the business with 14 reviews from three years ago, even when the second one does better work.
What does not decide it
Money paid to Google. Its help page says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. The ads you see at the top marked "Sponsored" are separate, bought and labelled as ads. They do not move you into the three underneath. Anyone selling you a guaranteed spot in the map pack is selling something Google says it does not sell.
The ten-minute check
You need a phone and a notepad. Do these in order.
-
Search like a customer, not like the owner (2 minutes)
Open a private or incognito tab so your own history does not colour the result. Search for the service, not your business name. Everyone shows up for their own name, so that tells you nothing. Try two or three phrasings a customer would actually use. If you can, do it from where your customers are, or ask someone across town to search and send you a screenshot. Write down the three names you see each time.
-
Look at your own profile (2 minutes)
Now search your business name and open your profile. If you see "Own this business?", the profile is not claimed and anyone can suggest changes to it. Claim and verify it first; Google says a verified business is more likely to show up. Then check the basics: phone number, hours, website link, address or service area. Tap the website link and the phone number to make sure both work. Hours deserve a second look, especially around holidays.
-
Compare your category with the three (2 minutes)
Open each of the three businesses from step one. Their primary category shows just under the name. If all three say "Plumber" and yours says something broader, that alone can explain a lot. Change your primary category to the one that matches the search you want to win, and add secondary categories for the other things you really do.
-
Count reviews, and look at the dates (2 minutes)
For each of the three, note the number of reviews and how recent the newest few are. Then do the same for yours. The star rating matters less than people think; the count and the recency are usually where the gap is. If they have ten times your reviews, you now know the job. The fix is not clever: ask every customer who is happy with the work, and make it easy by sending the review link from your profile in a text the same day.
-
Check that you say the same thing everywhere (2 minutes)
Look at the footer of your website, your Apple Maps listing and your Yelp page. Is the business name, address and phone number the same as on Google, written the same way? An old phone number on a directory, or a previous address on your own site, gives Google a reason to trust your details less. Write down every mismatch and fix them one at a time.
One more thing you might notice. If a competitor's name on Google is stuffed with keywords, like "Best Cheap Plumber Calgary 24/7", that breaks Google's guidelines, which say the name should be the business's real-world name. You can use "Suggest an edit" on their profile. Do not do it to yours; it can get a profile suspended.
What this check will not fix
Distance. If a customer is searching from the far side of the city and three good businesses are closer to them, a perfect profile may still not put you in their three. That is not a failure. Aim to own the three for the area you actually serve, and do not pay anyone who promises the whole city.
It also will not fix a profile in one afternoon. Changing a category or hours is quick. Building up reviews takes months of asking. Most of what moves you into the three is boring and steady, which is good news, because your competitors mostly are not doing it.
The map pack matters more each year, and not only for people. In the US, Google's AI has started phoning the businesses it finds in local results to ask about price. I wrote about that in Google's AI is calling businesses for prices.
If you would rather someone kept all of this right every month, that is the work Tala Works does for Calgary and Alberta businesses. The free scan on our homepage checks your Google, Apple Maps and Yelp listings to start.
Run the free scanSources
- Google Business Profile Help, Tips to improve your local ranking on Google. Relevance, distance and prominence; reviews; verification; "no way to request or pay for a better local ranking".
- Google Business Profile Help, Guidelines for representing your business on Google. Business names should match the real-world name.